perl.qpsmtpd...Re: svn:qpsmtpd r923 - in trunk: . libQpsmtpd by Radu Greab- June 3, 2008 Matt Sergeant wrote:> > > I find that "Unknown" as a value for remote_host looks more reasonable> > than NXDOMAIN and the other values.> > Why That&39;s less information. Unknown for NXDOMAIN always made sense. > But "Unknown" in the case of a DNS timeout or a failure never made > sense to me.It is less information, but is not a surprising behavior for someone whoused MTAs like postfix and sendmail, which use "remote_ip" in casethere is.http://www.nntp.perl.org/group/perl.qpsmtpd/2008/06/msg8084.html Re: svn:qpsmtpd r923 - in trunk: . libQpsmtpd by Chris Lewis- June 2, 2008 Matt Sergeant wrote:>> The Received headers won&39;t change. Only the logs created by logterse or>> other logging plugins that use remote_host will change.That&39;s a very very bad idea.How, exactly, are we supposed to have a plugin filter on NXDOMAIN and not TIMEOUT, or be able to detect DNS problemsDo the rDNS again Ick.> Wow, that seems MUCH worse to me - to have the logs not storing the > dns failure reason seems completely at odds to me with what logs should > be...http://www.nntp.perl.org/group/perl.qpsmtpd/2008/06/msg8083.html Re: svn:qpsmtpd r923 - in trunk: . libQpsmtpd by Ask Bjrn Hansen- June 2, 2008 On Jun 2, 2008, at 7:04 PM, Matt Sergeant wrote:> Wow, that seems MUCH worse to me - to have the logs not storing > the dns failure reason seems completely at odds to me with what logs > should be for.I agree with that. Failures of any kind should always be logged. - ask-- http:develooper.com - http:askask.comhttp://www.nntp.perl.org/group/perl.qpsmtpd/2008/06/msg8082.html Re: svn:qpsmtpd r923 - in trunk: . libQpsmtpd by Matt Sergeant- June 2, 2008 On 2-Jun-08, at 6:06 PM, Radu Greab wrote:> Matt Sergeant wrote:>>>>> I think that remote_host should not be the error code in case of>>> errors. That contradicts the description of the method and may force>>> other people using remote_host to do their own checks.>>>> Well on regular qmail it&39;s set to "Unknown" in case of errors, but>> never tells you if the error was NXDOMAIN or SERVFAIL or TIMEOUT. I>> find the...http://www.nntp.perl.org/group/perl.qpsmtpd/2008/06/msg8081.html |